In Partnership with
Even commercial brokers don’t like getting ghosted
Brokers want funders they can count on. La Trobe Financial and top commercial lending experts discuss certainty, structuring and where deals are heading
Cory Bannister
La Trobe Financial
Industry experts
Jeremy Enconniere
La Trobe Financial
Blake Murray
Blue Crane Capital
Clare George
Loan Market Group
Cory Bannister is senior vice president and chief lending officer (CLO) at La Trobe Financial. Bannister has over 20 years of experience in financial services and has held a number of positions across credit and distribution since joining the business in 2000. As CLO, he is focused on managing relationships with substantial wholesale and retail investors. Bannister holds diplomas in mortgage lending and business accounting and resides in Melbourne.
La Trobe Financial
Cory Bannister
Jeremy Enconniere is based in Melbourne and is part of La Trobe Financial’s real estate credit finance division. As a specialist commercial analyst, he manages major client and broker relationships across Australia, specialising in commercial credit and development finance. Enconniere has over seven years of experience in banking and financial services, including the mortgage industry, with expertise in lending, distressed asset management and credit within the non-bank sector. His deep understanding of complex debt structuring helps him achieve the best outcomes for La Trobe Financial’s clients.
La Trobe Financial
Jeremy Enconniere
Blake Murray brings 11 years of banking and finance experience to every client relationship, with a focus on residential, commercial and construction property finance. What sets him apart is his genuine focus on the long term. He is less interested in one-off transactions than in building relationships clients can come back to, deal after deal. Murray takes the time to understand each client’s goals, translating lender policy into plain English and keeping them informed from application to settlement. With access to Blue Crane Capital’s full lender panel, including banks, non-banks and private funders, Murray works to find the right solution for every application and the right partner for the long run.
Blue Crane Capital
Blake Murray
Clare George is associate director of commercial finance at Loan Market Group (LMG), where she provides the group’s brokers with dedicated commercial finance expertise. She combines a lender’s understanding of credit with practical knowledge of the broker channel. Her years in business banking and private client roles at NAB and St. George have given her insight into how banks assess commercial borrowers, while her partnership work at St. George and FAST Group has built her experience supporting brokers directly. George holds diplomas in accounting and financial services.
Loan Market Group
Clare George
Matthew Paterson is a commercial broker and director at Partnership Finance Group. He has 20 years of experience in the finance industry, primarily focused on property finance across New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria. His career in property finance was developed at St. George Bank and the Commonwealth Bank. Paterson's expertise has been developed on a wide range of transactions, including construction loans, mezzanine finance, residual stock loans, preferred equity and commercial property loans. During his career, he has arranged financing ranging from $2 million to more than $100 million for several well-known property companies. He has also built a strong network within the property industry and assists clients in delivering end-to-end project solutions by engaging the appropriate industry professionals to ensure the right financing is obtained.
Partnership Finance Group
Matthew Paterson
“Because of our diversified funding platform, the challenge for us is not liquidity. If a deal is presented to us and it’s feasible, we’ll get behind it”
Cory Bannister,La Trobe Financial
GETTING STOOD up at the last minute is a quick way to destroy trust.
In commercial broking, the equivalent is a lender failing to deliver when settlement day arrives. And according to many brokers, that’s become an increasingly common concern in today’s funding market.
An offer is signed, a settlement date is booked, the client has let all parties know finance is in place. Then they are ghosted.
“Luckily, touch wood, nothing’s happened to me,” said Matthew Paterson, commercial broker and director at Partnership Finance Group. “But there’s been a number of horror stories where offers have been put forward, and settlements have been put at risk or haven’t occurred because the lender hasn’t turned up with the money.”
“The most challenging at the moment is probably mid-market development. Getting valuations to stack up, presales, lender appetite in the private credit space tightening up, it’s just proving a lot more difficult”
Blake Murray, Blue Crane Capital
“A 75% LVR isn’t really available at the moment competitively; 70 is becoming the new 75. And what that’s creating in the market is that it’s making deals unfeasible”
Matthew Paterson, Partnership Finance Group
Developers still have projects to deliver, residential investors are actively inquiring about commercial property, and small businesses are restructuring debt. More businesses are also being formed, which leads to a need for more business premises. That demand is now flowing toward lenders with deep capital and toward brokers who can structure around the gaps left by banks trimming gearing and private credit funds short of investor money.
Loan Market Group’s panel data shows how far the flow has already shifted toward non-banks.
“We’re seeing the major bank market share slowly decline over the years. Last financial year, it was 68%, and the non-bank second tier was definitely coming up at 28%, with private lending specialists at 4%. My disclaimer there is that’s only what we see on panel … the private and specialised would be way bigger than that,” said Clare George, associate director of commercial finance at Loan Market Group (LMG).
“Across commercial opportunities of scale, whether pre-development or built form, we’re consistently seeing experienced, well-credentialed sponsors leading transactions”
Jeremy Enconniere,La Trobe Financial
At the smaller end of the market, competition among non-banks has stayed lively while the pressure has landed elsewhere.
“In the lower-end commercial space, there’s a lot of competition. There’s plenty of others in the space that are trying to [nip] at La Trobe Financial’s heels, which is healthy competition. But on the flip side, the private credit space has tightened up substantially. So I guess people like La Trobe with a big investor base are probably benefiting off the back of that,” said Blake Murray, director and finance broker at Blue Crane Capital.
Character counts
With presales thin and values softer, credit teams are leaning harder on the oldest test in lending.
“A client that has done 20 deals over the last 10 years, you can look them in the eye and know that they’ll deliver the project, and they’ve got the experience and they’ve got the staff and they’ve got the right builder. It sounds simple, but that’s how they’re getting across the line. Right now, with the tightening over the last six months, presales are difficult and values are down. So you’ve really got to look at the other characteristics of credit, and one of the major ones is character,” Paterson explained.
Enconniere traced that shift to the end of a period when almost anyone could assemble a joint venture.
Such incidents have made many commercial brokers, understandably, a little wary about whether the funds for a deal are truly there.
“You can’t put all your money on one horse at the moment. You’ve got to talk to three or four different groups and be certain that you’ve got a couple of offers,” said Paterson.
For La Trobe Financial, leaving a deal out in the cold due to funding reasons is not only bad etiquette but something it has built its business to avoid. “Because of our diversified funding platform, the challenge for us is not liquidity. If a deal is presented to us and it’s feasible, we’ll get behind it,” said Cory Bannister, senior vice president and chief lending officer at La Trobe Financial.
Tighter capital has also tested how much of the demand for commercial funding was ever about cheap money.
“For a long time, I felt much of the demand in the larger commercial market was being driven by the availability of abundant capital. While that capital has clearly tightened, the need from developers and clients remains. In many ways, it’s reassuring to see these projects being driven by genuine demand and the need to deliver them, rather than simply by access to cheap funding. That gives me confidence that, all things being equal, activity should remain relatively strong over the next 12 to 24 months,” said Jeremy Enconniere, head of commercial partnerships at La Trobe Financial.
Why structuring is replacing leverage
Bank appetite has split into two, with plenty of hunger for income-producing assets and very little for anything still being built.
“On the commercial real estate investment side, the banks are chasing hard. Construction for them is difficult at the moment because there aren’t strong enough risk mitigants at times to enable financing of those deals. So they’re chasing passive investment pretty hard. I’ve run a few tenders recently on that and pricing is very strong,” Paterson said.
Developers that expanded their pipelines when New South Wales planning reforms opened up more sites have felt the tightening most.
“For the banks, when the market starts to come off, two of their quickest triggers to mitigate risk are to increase presale coverage and reduce gearing. And that’s counterproductive to a client delivering a project. Particularly at the moment, when in New South Wales, all the planning changes have enabled clients to look at three or four deals at one time rather than one or two, they’re committed to those projects. When the gearing or presale coverage changes, the gestation period to get it underway is longer, and the equity requirement for three or four becomes five or six,” Paterson explained.
On the construction side, the conversation with clients has moved from price to how much a lender will put in.
“A 75% LVR isn’t really available at the moment competitively; 70 is becoming the new 75. And what that’s creating in the market is that it’s making deals unfeasible,” Paterson added.
His answer to the shortfall is a second layer of debt, and he expects to see plenty more of it.
“There is going to be a position where, on the construction side, instead of having a stretched senior transaction at 75 or sometimes higher, there’s going to be a first and second position to reset those deals, either with the one lender, or the existing lender carries that behind so they get paid out. So the structuring is going to be important because no one wants to be trying to take deals into the market that are mortgagee in possession and trying to sell them in this market,” Paterson said.
Mezzanine money sitting behind a bank still leaves a developer to find the last slice of the stack. “Where’s the rest of the equity coming from? You might end up having a net profit of $5 million, but you don’t want to put in much of your own money. You’d prefer to fund that through different capital structures,” Ashcroft said.
Bannister was speaking to Australian Broker at Shangri-La Sydney restaurant alongside a group of commercial mortgage brokers and financial service experts. That theme of certainty surfaced repeatedly throughout the discussion. While demand for commercial finance remains strong, brokers said changing capital market conditions mean borrowers are placing greater value on lenders that can not only approve deals but reliably settle them.
Over lunch, the group talked through where the opportunities sit and what it takes to close them.
Certainty of funding matters more than ever
Demand for commercial finance remains strong although the market is undergoing change. Commercial property sales in Australia rose at a brisk pace in the six months to June, with the volume and number of deals 21% higher than a year earlier, according to the Sep 2026 commercial property update from realcommercial.com.au.
Within those figures, La Trobe Financial’s share of lending at the aggregator has accelerated. “It just goes to show that La Trobe is now number four in our market share nationally, and number three in New South Wales. That’s the first time that’s happened,” George added.
Refinancing is one of the busiest channels for that business, as borrowers from both the bank and private credit camps look for lenders still writing deals.
“We’re currently seeing an increase in refinance activity, both from banks and non-banks and the private credit sector. I think the capital markets have narrowed a little bit and are likely to continue to narrow early in the new year. Banks are tightening their approach to credit, and a number of lenders in the private credit sector have temporarily paused funding, which produces some good opportunity,” Bannister said.
Where has all the private money gone?
Since the collapse of Sydney developer Bathla Group in August, several private credit managers have frozen or limited withdrawals. Metrics Credit Partners alone has locked up funds holding more than $9 billion. Stretched senior loans, once a speciality of private funds, have been among the first casualties.
“I would say private has gone, and that’s where you used to get your stretched senior position. It’s not gone forever, but it’s going through a really tough time. So what could have been private is now going to lenders like La Trobe who do accommodate within that capital stack and structure to allow that second mortgage or mezz when it comes to construction,” said Melissa Ashcroft, managing director of AAA Mortgages.
The majors have spotted the opening as well, and some are arriving with partners in tow.
“I’m also seeing the banks trying to make a comeback, particularly in development, where I’m trying to refinance loans that are in private to bank, and they’re going, ‘We’re happy to go to say 65[% LVR], maybe 70 on one or two, and this is our preferred mezz provider.’ So they’re actually coming to the party with a family office they’re happy to allow to sit behind to get them to 75 or maybe 80,” Ashcroft added.
Read on
When the valuation runs ahead of the approval
Rising bond yields carry an awkward implication for every investment-grade asset on a lender’s books. Australia’s 10-year government bond yield has climbed to about 5.3%, roughly a full percentage point higher than a year ago. The Reserve Bank’s latest Financial Stability Review shows the buffer between commercial property yields and that risk-free rate has shrunk to its narrowest since around 2008.
“If bond yields continue to increase, what does that do to commercial real estate yields and effectively the valuations of those? Historically, a lot of those traditional commercial real estate investment assets have traded between 4% and 5.5%. If bond yields are already sitting at 5.5%, where should those be traded at? That’s obviously going to depress valuations, and there could be some pain there,” Paterson said.
Asked which deals are hardest to place, Enconniere pointed to a category that ought to look like a windfall for its owners.
“One of the more complex and challenging deals to assess would have to be TOD (transport-oriented development program) and LMR (low and mid-rise housing) pre-development sites. On the surface, it’s fair to describe that market as softer than it was a few years ago. Yet we’re still seeing examples where sites acquired for $15 million are now worth $35 million. You need to do the work to reconcile and seek comfort around that,” Enconniere said.
The rezoning of these sites has, in many cases, handed owners a large valuation uplift on paper even as the housing market those projects will eventually sell into has turned softer. Lenders are left to decide how much of that uplift to believe.
Part of the problem sits with borrowers who mistake an early planning milestone for the finish line.
“Every client who gets an expression of interest recommended by the government at the moment and then gets the SEAR (Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements) approval believes they’ve got an approval, but they haven’t got a development application yet. So they think their $15 million site is worth $35 million,” Paterson said.
Further down the scale, smaller developers that budgeted for a kinder market are feeling it, too.
“The most challenging at the moment is probably mid-market development. Getting valuations to stack up, presales, lender appetite in the private credit space tightening up, it’s just proving a lot more difficult. And the clients are probably needing to put in more money,” Murray said.
“Twelve months ago, a greater availability of capital meant developers had more avenues to assemble sites and bring projects together often through joint venture structures. Fast forward to today, and funding is more selective. As a result, across commercial opportunities of scale, whether pre-development or built form, we’re consistently seeing experienced, well-credentialed sponsors leading transactions,” Enconniere said.
At La Trobe Financial, the first question asked of a difficult deal concerns the way out.
“A key consideration for our credit team is the exit strategy. It doesn’t need to be short term, but it does need to be clearly defined and supported by the sponsor’s financial capacity. Where projects have a longer investment horizon, we’re looking for sponsors with the balance sheet strength to execute their plan. Ultimately, we’re focused on backing opportunities that have a credible pathway to completion, rather than those that depend on a favourable change in market conditions,” Bannister said.
Holding its credit appetite steady through the boom years has left La Trobe Financial well placed now that others are pulling back.
“Our approach hasn’t changed with the cycle. When capital was flowing freely, we weren’t increasing leverage or easing credit standards to chase growth, and we’re not tightening our philosophy now that conditions are more challenging. By maintaining a consistent and disciplined approach, we’re finding that many of the sponsors coming to market today are experienced, well-capitalised and aligned with the way we like to do business,” Bannister added.
The borrowers coming through those gates are playing a longer game than they once did.
“It’s become less transactional and more of a relationship or holistic approach to credit. Maybe it’s a bit like checkers to chess in a sense. People are now thinking well ahead. It’s not just about the one loan in front of them,” Bannister explained.
La Trobe Financial is Australia’s premier alternative asset manager and a proven and trusted investment partner for institutional and retail investors, with c. $20 billion in assets under management. We believe that property and homeownership are the foundations of wealth creation and financial independence. That is why we have created a broad range of lending solutions to suit your needs at every life stage, from buying your first home to building your business and maximising your SMSF and retirement income.
Find out more
Share
Published 23 Nov 2026
Melissa Ashcroft
AAA Mortgages
Matthew Paterson
Partnership Finance Group
Melissa Ashcroft is managing director of AAA Mortgages. Her specialism is the full capital structure: advising developers across the project life cycle, structuring lending across entities and trusts, and matching deals to the right funder from more than 80 lenders. She was the only woman on MPA’s Top 10 Commercial Brokers list in 2021 and won Commercial Finance Broker of the Year at the Women in Finance Awards in 2022 and 2025. She sits on the MFAA board as a non-executive director.
AAA Mortgages
Melissa Ashcroft
Brokers writing commercial, business or asset finance by state
Source: MFAA State of Mortgage & Finance Broking Report 2026
2024
2025
Ashcroft’s prescription for newcomers is to start with the easier stuff.
“Lease doc is a great commercial product that not many people know about, and it’s available at banks and non-banks like La Trobe Financial. It’s a great entry-level way to work out how to do commercial deals. Work out what business bank means at Westpac and how that’s different to NAB. Educate and inform yourself, and then when those opportunities come, you’ll be more capable of understanding how to work out the solution,” Ashcroft said.
For brokers already established in commercial, checking a lender’s capital before trusting it with a client has always been routine.
“I don’t really think much differently needs to be done if you’re a broker who’s been in the commercial space for a long time already. Twelve months ago, there were new avenues to capital coming up regularly, brokers had to vet them hard to ensure they actually had depth of capital and that they could deliver. That’s only more heightened now in the current environment, but experienced brokers have already developed good practices and will likely keep the same stride and pick up clients as they come along in the next 12 months,” Enconniere said.
LMG is also working to take some of the friction out of commercial submissions. “The more we can digitalise our commercial deals, the better it is going to be and the safer it’s going to be,” George said.
Technology will only take a newcomer so far, though. “We don’t really want everybody to be writing all commercial deals. The complex needs to stay with the specialists and expert brokers,” George added.
With her firm working in commercial and construction lending since the 1980s, Ashcroft still meets deals that test her, and she knows where to take them. “I know if I bring anything to [La Trobe Financial], even after all these years when I still get stumped on things, they’ll be able to help me,” Ashcroft said.
For commercial brokers, certainty of execution has become just as valuable as pricing. In a changing market, lenders that communicate clearly, structure creatively and ultimately deliver when settlement day arrives are likely to remain front of mind.
Small businesses under strain offer another stream of work, much of it tied to what they owe the tax office.
“There’s $60 billion of tax debt out there at the moment. So looking at restructuring financing, helping clients get out of that little bit of a hole that they’re in, and a lot of cash flow, working capital. I think SMEs are struggling at the moment, so they’re looking for those unsecured loans or cash out just to help them move along,” George said.
More than half of SMEs that require additional finance over the upcoming three months need it for cash flow or working capital, according to Fifth Quadrant’s Sep 2026 SME Sentiment Tracker.
“Small balance commercial is starting to receive a lot of enquiries but is yet to materialise into a lot of deal flow. But certainly, investors are turning their attention to commercial following the changes that were made to negative gearing and the like in the residential space,” Bannister said.
For investors used to residential tenancies, the length of a commercial lease can come as a pleasant surprise. “You’ve got to think about it; it’s not an annual lease. It can be a five or 10-year investment opportunity. So there’s a long-term nature to commercial securities,” Ashcroft said.
The entity holding the asset can shape the outcome as much as the asset itself.
“It’s about understanding how to structure deals for clients, especially if they’re an investor moving into the commercial space. So looking at borrowing entities, looking at how that works and the ripple-through effect on tax. It’s smarter capital and smarter structuring,” Ashcroft added.
Residential brokers test the waters
Policy changes on the residential side have pushed a fresh cohort of brokers toward commercial security.
“We’ve talked about diversification for years and years, but I think the new budget has forced their hand. I’ve got lots of enquiries at the moment, and they’re SMSFs. They’re pretty easy to write if you’re a resi broker and just moving over to a commercial security really,” George said.
La Trobe Financial is fielding similar calls, although the conversion into volume is still to come.
NSW/ACT 3,875
VIC
3,415
QLD
1,912
WA
1,125
SA
651
NT
32
TAS
74
NSW/ACT 4,066
QLD
2,066
WA
1,159
SA
672
NT
30
VIC
3,700
TAS
92
From left: Blake Murray, Blue Crane Capital; Melissa Ashcroft, AAA Mortgages; Cory Bannister, La Trobe Financial; Clare George, Loan Market Group; Jeremy Enconniere, La Trobe Financial; Matthew Paterson, Partnership Finance Group
Source: MFAA State of Mortgage & Finance Broking Report 2026
Brokers writing commercial, business or asset finance
“I’ve got lots of enquiries at the moment, and they’re SMSFs. They’re pretty easy to write if you’re a resi broker and just moving over to a commercial security really”
Clare George,Loan Market Group
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
2024
2025
11,084
11,785
60
50
40
30
20
10
2024
2025
53.3%
51.9%
Number of brokers
Proportion of total
The banks have quietly improved their SME offering even as full-doc commercial deals have become harder to land with them.
“In the bank space, meeting commercial requirements is getting difficult for a full-document commercial transaction. Things like tax debt, and just meeting serviceability requirements with the buffers in place, are getting more and more difficult. But the area where I think the banks have actually been very good recently is the SME space where their policies have improved dramatically. They’ve essentially got low-doc lending, just BAS (business activity statements) or self-declarations, at full-doc rates,” Murray explained.
Not every newcomer is ready for complex commercial work, and the lenders are drawing their own lines.
“I find that the banks, the majors and the other banks are really curbing who they’re giving accreditation to. They’re scrutinising it more and more. So I’m having this conversation every single day, telling our brokers, ‘I’m sorry, but you can’t get accreditation’,” George said.
Regulatory attention gives LMG another reason to match each deal with the right lender.
“If it is an easy deal that should be with a non-bank, go for it, and they’re going to hold your hand through it. If it should be with a major, do not put it with somebody else because I think that’s just going to get us into trouble. We’re going to have AFCA complaints. ASIC is already eyeing us up, so we’ve got to be super careful there,” George added.
“If you’re diversifying, seek out someone within the lending world that can help you because complex is complex. It’s called complex for a reason”
Melissa Ashcroft, AAA Mortgages
What do brokers want from lenders?
Despite differing views on opportunities and risks, the panel was largely aligned on what brokers need most from lending partners in the current environment.
Murray came to the question with a checklist.
“Firstly, certainty. With these complex transactions, there might be four or five key risks that you workshop upfront, so getting certainty over those issues means we’re all on the same page and know from an early point in the conversation that these won’t become issues later. Second is transparency
and communication. Third is flexibility and problem-solving. I’m seeing far fewer easy transactions where there aren’t a few hairs that you need to navigate. And then finally, it’s speed because speed is the killer of most deals if you don’t get them across the line quick enough,” Murray said.
Speed is the hardest item on that list to guarantee while so few lenders have capital to deploy, and a slow decline can cost a client more than a quick one.
“Direct access to the credit decision-makers would be nice to have. I hear a lot that there’s a long, drawn-out process to an eventual no to a deal, and they’ve already wasted three or four weeks on it. A fast no is better than a maybe,” George said.
Brokers stepping into commercial for the first time should pick their lender contact with care.
“What they need from the lender the most is a BDM or a banker or someone who knows what’s going on, not just a salesperson. If you’re diversifying, seek out someone within the lending world that can help you because complex is complex. It’s called complex for a reason. Don’t try it if you haven’t got someone on your side who gets it,” Ashcroft said.
Bring the problems early
Bannister’s request of brokers starts well before an application is lodged.
“The successful brokers engage with their BDM or really fine-tune the transaction before it’s even launched. And I would say focus on the challenging aspects of the application first because they’re not going to go away, and lenders are likely to home in on those,” Bannister said.
Brokers who bury a weakness in the hope that credit will miss it are misreading the lender’s temperament. “If there’s a challenge, great. That’s the business we’re in. Complexity is why we win business. So we like complexity, we understand it. For many in our office, I think it’s their passion to deal with complexity,” Bannister added.
The planning horizon is lengthening for brokers as well as their clients.
“It’s really important, more so now than ever, to have a deep relationship and understanding of your client. That enables you to forecast the requirements over the next period, so you’re on the front foot. If you’re planning ahead six months, 12 months, whatever it is, you’re not chasing your tail a month out from when funds are required, and that’s when you get yourself in a position where you need to take terms that aren’t at the level you could have got if you planned a bit earlier,” Murray said.
